How to Compare Financial Advisors When You're Paid in Equity

Comparing financial advisors should be easy. Then you open three advisor websites and they all look the same: acronyms after their names, a fee based on your investment balance, and a promise to look at your whole financial picture. (Ours says a version of that too. It's hard not to.)

None of that is wrong. It just doesn't separate anyone. The differences show up when you ask questions whose answers depend on your equity, like whether the fee applies to shares you haven't vested yet, or how they'd help you decide when to exercise your options and how many shares to sell.

Here's what to ask, in the order that saves you the most time.

Credentials: What You Can Check Without Asking

Start with the part that doesn't need a meeting.

Every registered investment adviser files a Form ADV, and it's public. Search the firm or the person at adviserinfo.sec.gov and you'll see where they're registered, any disciplinary history, and the firm's brochure, where they have to explain in plain(ish) English how they're paid and what conflicts that creates. If the person also holds a brokerage license, FINRA's BrokerCheck shows that record too.

Three things to look for:

  • How they're paid. "Fee-only" means they only get paid by you. "Fee-based" sounds nearly identical and means fees plus commissions on products they sell. We're fee-only, and even so it doesn't remove every conflict (an advisor paid on your balance would rather you didn't use it to pay off the mortgage). What you're looking for is the fewest conflicts, and a clear answer about how they'd handle the ones that remain if you start working together.

  • Whether they're a fiduciary for the work you'd hire them for. A fiduciary must act in your best interest when they're advising you. Product sales are held to a lesser standard. Someone licensed to do both can move between the two inside the same relationship, so ask which standard applies to each thing they'd do for you.

  • The letters themselves. CFP® comes with an exam, an experience requirement, and an ethics standard. The CFP Board lists every certificant, along with any public discipline, at cfp.net. The CFA® charter is another one worth looking for, and CFA Institute keeps a member directory where you can look someone up.

This step takes ten minutes and rules people out. It can't rule anyone in. Everyone still standing will look qualified on paper, which is why the next four questions need a conversation.

Experience: Hand Them Your Hardest Decision

Years in business tells you how long someone has been doing the job. It says nothing about whether they've been doing the job you need.

So skip the résumé question. Pick a real decision sitting in front of you and ask how they'd approach it. If a large share of your net worth sits in one company's stock, ask how they'd decide how much of it to keep. If RSUs are a large part of your pay, ask how they'd help you at each vest. Then pay attention to what comes back first.

A strong answer starts with questions. What else is on your return this year? When does the next tranche vest? Do you need the cash, or is this about the tax? On a large company position, someone who has done this many times also asks what you paid for each lot, when your trading windows open, and what you'd want the money for, all before suggesting a number.

Be wary of an answer that arrives fully formed. Advice given without knowing the facts isn't good advice, however confident it sounds.

If you want a baseline to hold the answers against, our guides to RSUs and ISO taxation go through the decisions in detail.

Services: The Month Before Your Next Vest

What an advisor does is easy to list. When they do it tells you more. (Whether a broader scope is worth paying for at all is its own question, and we've written about that one separately.)

The equity-specific test is your calendar. Equity runs on dates: vests, trading windows if you're an insider, option expirations, the deadline to exercise what you've vested after you leave a job. Ask what they'd be doing in the month before the next one.

Here's why the timing matters. When RSUs vest, your employer withholds federal tax at the flat rate for supplemental wages, 22% on the first $1 million in 2026. At the incomes where RSUs are a large part of pay, that's well below the rate you're taxed at, and the difference waits for you in April. Adjusting for it throughout the year takes a few small changes to your estimated payments. Finding it in April is a bill plus, possibly, an underpayment penalty.

An advisor working from your equity calendar raises it before the vest. If the answer is that it comes up at the annual review, ask when the annual review is.

Fee Transparency: Which Balance Is the Fee On?

"A fee based on your investment balance" leaves one word doing a lot of work. Balance of what?

For most people the answer is obvious. When you're paid in equity, there are three places it can differ, and each one can move the bill by thousands a year:

  • Unvested grants. RSUs and options that haven't vested aren't yours yet. Ask whether they count toward the fee, and get the answer in writing.

  • Company stock you're holding. A large position you're keeping, or one you can only sell in a trading window, is often the part of your net worth an advisor touches least. Ask whether it's in the fee base, and at what rate.

  • Accounts they don't manage. Your 401(k) at work, a spouse's account at another firm. Some firms bill on everything they advise on, others only on what they hold. Either can be reasonable. You just need to know which you're comparing.

Then ask for the fee as a dollar figure on your own numbers.

Ours is on the pricing page: tiered, charged on the portfolio we manage, and not on your unvested equity.

Contract Terms: What Leaving Costs You

Nobody hires an advisor planning to leave. Read the exit terms anyway, because the expensive part of leaving usually sits outside the termination clause.

Ask this: if you leave, does everything transfer to the next firm as it is, or does anything have to be sold first?

When your accounts sit at a large independent custodian in your name, holding ordinary funds and stocks, everything moves in kind. Nothing has to be sold. When part of the portfolio is in a firm's own proprietary funds, or in products that charge you to get out, some of it may have to be sold or surrendered before it can move. In a taxable account with years of gains, that sale is a tax bill you never decided to take on.

The rest of the exit terms are in the advisory agreement and the Form ADV brochure: how much notice you have to give, whether fees you've paid in advance come back for the unused part of the quarter, and whether there's a fee to leave at all. Ask for a copy early, before you're attached to anyone.

Three Advisors, One Page

Ask every advisor the same questions, in the same order, and write the answers where you can see them side by side. Three conversations blur together by the third. Three columns on one page don't.

You're unlikely to find one advisor who wins every row. The rows that should decide it are the ones about your equity: whose walkthrough started with questions about your year, who knew what happens before a vest, and who gave you the fee in dollars without being asked twice.

Want this kind of thinking applied to your situation?

Want to run these questions on us? Start with a 30 to 45 minute Zoom call.

Book an Intro Call